I noticed that I wasn’t getting many mails (I need better monitoring), and discovered that my iredmail server was poorly.
I have spent far too much time and energy on getting it back and working these past few days, but I’ve finally got it back up and stable.
Some background: I’ve had iredmail running for probably going on 6 years now and have had very few issues at all. It runs on an Ubuntu VM on Proxmox and originally was running in the same VM on ESXi (I migrated it over). I haven’t changed anything to do with the VM for years other than the Ubuntu LTS updates every 2-3 years, it’s always been there and stable. I occasionally will update the Ubuntu OS and iredmail itself, no problems.
Back to the problem… I noticed that Postfix was running OK, but was showing a bunch of errors about clamav not being able to connect. Odd. I then noticed that amavis was not running and had seemed to just die. I couldn’t find any reason in any log file. Very strange. Bunch of hunting, checking config file history in the git repo. Nothing significant for years.
Find that restarting the server got everything back up and running. Great, lets go to bed… Wake up next morning to find that amavis was dead again - it only lasted about 40 mins and then just closed for no reason. Right, ok, time to turn off clamAV as that seemed be be coming up a bit wheilst looking, follow the guide, all is well. Hmm, this seems to be working, but I don’t really want clamav off. A whole bunch of duck duck going and I still couldn’t figure out a root cause.
And then it clicked, the thing that was causing amavis to close was that it was running out of memory and it was being killed. Bump the memory up to 4GB and re-enable everything as it originally was and… it seems to have worked. Been going strong for over a day now.
I don’t know what it was that’s changed recently which has meant the memory requirements have gone up a bit, but at least it’s now fixed and it took all of 2 minutes to adjust.
The joys of selfhosting!
Unless of course you have a dynamic ip address.
Unfortunately, in that case you will have to rely on a vm on some external provider or a smtp relay service external to your network.
I opted for a vm on the cloud, because at home I have a CGNAT network with no ip.
Honestly you’re generally going to have a better time with email if you outsource it. There are just so many “oops lost email” scenarios.
Ah sorry, I thought we were in a community that deals with self-hosting.
If you prefer to use a free provider to also have to see advertisements in addition to spam, go ahead.
If you prefer to use one for a fee because you are not able to manage it on your own, go ahead.
It’s the beauty of open protocols.
Email is one of those things that virtually everyone agrees is better off not self hosted. Similar to how most in the cooking world agree you shouldn’t be making fugu at home. Though admittedly, usually no one dies if you fuck up your email server.
It’s just a myth put around by some inexperienced user who has tried to set up a mail server or more likely by large companies who wants to give you ‘for free’ the service.
It was actually much more difficult to manage them many years ago when you had to invent by hand how to filter spam. Now with common standards supported by many pre-packaged solutions, everything is much simpler and accessible to the less experienced. Of course, I admit that it takes a minimum of experience to make a backup of a text file containing the mailboxes and this could definitely be the toughest challenge 🙄.
The potential for data loss is more catastrophic, a misconfiguration can go unnoticed for long periods of time, your IP can be listed as spam without notification, and more. Not to mention, short term downtime of a couple days can result in loss of emails.
Is it easy to spin up a docker image and call it a day? Certainly. But there is a lot more involved in a healthy email server, and there are a lot of pitfalls.
Again ? We are in a self-hosting community and users must be helped to be autonomous, e-mail is a service that needs to be regained more than others, especially now that it is easier to manage and is for the most part hostage of large companies that make their own interests at the expense of users.
Someone will make mistakes , someone will miss a few emails and it is absolutely normal and physiological as for all kinds of services.
I got tired of discussing it with you, Your attitude is neither appropriate nor constructive for this community.
Welcome to my blocklist.
Oh no.
Anyway.
Edit: lmao just realized, you upvote your own comments from any alt. It’s the only thing that explains you having got +1 on a comment within 3 minutes of posting, on a 4 day old thread.